For the first time EVER, I went to return two out of three items (a small messenger bag and a tote). The reason for the return? "Style not as expected" In one case, the bag was unsuited for a laptop because it wasn't padded on the bottom. In the other, it was just super awkward to use.
So I was pretty much blown away when I got to the finalize return page and it showed an $8.03 return shipping charge. WTH? I didn't click through and immediately contacted Amazon Customer Service via online chat.
While in the end, the CS rep put through a manual return without the return shipping charge, my experience was a huge step down from previous contacts with Amazon. First, the rep said it was a re-stocking fee, not a shipping charge. What?? Nope it said SHIPPING on the page. Second, the rep never answered my question about how one would know about the charge in advance. He (Steven S.) simply pasted a link to Amazon's general return policies. And finally when I AGAIN tried to get a further explanation about how to figure things out in the future, he simply LEFT CHAT leaving me hanging.
After this episode, just to double-check, I went to Amazon's help pages and looked for info on returns and couldn't find anything specific that dealt with Prime and shipping charges on returns.
After posting my story on Facebook tonight, I immediately got 3 replies from friends who have recently had the same thing happen to them AND had never had it happen before. One friend commented that Amazon customer service has gone downhill in general. She noted when items are delayed in shipping (the famous "Order now and get it by xx/xx/xx"), Amazon no longer compensates in some way. They simply say "check with us in a few days".
Relaying my experience on Twitter got this response from Amazon:
This sucks and nowhere has Amazon informed its customers up front that they're now doing this. So I predict a few things will happen:
- Customers will do far less shopping on "spec" items or where they're not sure about the quality, fit, color or finish.
- Any returns that aren't "free returns" will be "defective" in some respect.
- Prime members may reconsider paying $120/year for "free" shipping.
- More shopping will be done at retailers like Staples, Wal-Mart or Best Buy where you can return items no charge at a physical store.


